SC to soon implement Neutral Citation System
Feb 23, 2023
New Delhi [India], February 24 : The Supreme Court of India will soon implement a uniform, reliable and secure methodology known as the 'Neutral Citation System' for identifying and citing decisions for all its judgments, as announced by the Chief Justice of India Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, said a press release.
The system shall make it easier for Courts to publish the judgements in the public domain by providing a consistent method of citing judicial decisions, added the press release.
The Chief Justice of India had directed for evolving a mechanism for standardizing citations, particularly for easing the adjudicatory process and to avoid confusion arising out of one case being cited by different people in a number of different ways, as they may rely upon different sources to read the reported case laws, as per the statement.
A few decades ago, the exercise of citing cases was simple because the number
of litigation was low, resulting in fewer judicial pronouncements, which were
reported manageably by a handful of official law reporters.
The scenario has undergone a radical change, as the number of litigation has
escalated exponentially, thus paving way for numerous law reports. Additionally,
several websites have started reporting case laws online owing to the development of
IT facilities.
A 'Sub-Committee' for formulating a standard national model for Neutral
Citations for judgments rendered by the Supreme Court of India and the High Courts, were constituted by the Hon'ble Chief Justice of India. The Sub-Committee invited suggestions, deliberated upon various facets of the Neutral Citation System and held a considered view that a uniform national model of generating and allocating neutral
citations should be adopted.
'Neutral Citation' would be a Court's approved citation system, which would
be independent of the series of Law Reports or other publications, and unique to each decision. Every order and judgment (reportable and non-reportable) of the
Supreme Court of India would have a citation of its own, facilitating easy
identification, referencing and retrieval.
The legacy data for judgments and orders shall be considered for seeding
neutral citations retrospectively. In the e-SCR module, the neutral citation number shall be seeded along with SCR number, which will be shown distinctly. As regards live
data, i.e., orders and judgments w.e.f. 01.01.2023, shall be assigned neutral citations at the time of their publishing on the official website.
Access to case law is an important facet of the rule of law. It helps in providing
transparency and predictability concerning the settled legal position. It also aids in
enhancing public scrutiny, education, academic research and the development of law.
This initiative of the Chief Justice of India will revolutionize the pattern in which the citations operate. Such access to citations, which was so far available only to the subscription holders of private law reporters, would now be available to everyone free of cost' in the reformed and indigenous form of 'Neutral.
